Katherine Carlin (Jenkins), What a Catch (PEOPLE 2026)

‘What a catch’ is a satirical response to the familiar dating-app trope: men posing proudly with fish as proof of masculinity, success, or desirability. By isolating the subject in a controlled studio environment and exaggerating the trope, the work exposes the performative nature of online dating imagery. The portraits feature male subjects nude, holding fish positioned to obscure or interrupt the expected focal points of the body. The fish becomes both prop and punchline—an object of pride that simultaneously conceals, mocks, and replaces the subject’s attempt at self-presentation. By removing the outdoor, “authentic” fishing context and replacing it with stark studio lighting, the images highlight how identity is staged rather than lived. The fish, often meant to signal competence or virility, instead reads as awkward, absurd, and oddly vulnerable.

Images have been resized for web display, which may cause some loss of image quality. Note: Original high-resolution images are used for judging.